Introduction the potential for conflict between the application of the hague visby rules 1 and the united states 1936 carriage of goods by sea act us cogsa 2 is apparent from their terms, us cogsa covering cargo shipped into and out of the united states and hague visby covering cargo from a hague visby country coming into the united states. Unlike cogsa, but similar to the hague visby rules, the rotterdam rules establish an alternative weight limitation. Carriage of goods by sea act 1971 which brought into force the hague visby rules. Hague rules, hague visby rules, hamburg rules and the rotterdam rules.
For instance, although article ic of the rules exempts live animals and deck cargo, section 17 restores those items into the category of goods. Carriage of goods by sea act 1971 cogsa 71 is a uk act to make the hague visby rules apply to the carriage of goods in certain circumstances. Hague visby rules means the hague rules as amended by the protocol signed at brussels on 23rd february 1968. United states applies cogsa the hague rules6 in the same way. This is the name given to the legislation enacted in the united kingdom. The carriage of goods by sea act 1971 incorporates the hague visby rules into english law. The act implements the hague visby rules with some differences, especially related to the application of the rules. States and the hague visby rules as adopted by other nations in a number of respects, making some changes both in terms of concepts and in substance. Unless stated, this publication will focus on the application of the hague. Hague visby rules hague visby rules come into operation where a bill of lading or similar document of title covers the contract of carriage by sea article i b section 1b of the u. There are currently no known outstanding effects for the carriage of goods by sea act 1971. Carriage of goods by sea act 1971 wikimili, the free.
In other words, a shipment from england to australia would be subject to the uk carriage of goods by sea act 1971, because that act applies by force of law to outward shipments from england. Carriage of goods by sea act 1971 cogsa 71 carriage of goods by sea act 1971 cogsa 71 is a uk act to make the hague visby rules apply to the carriage of goods in certain circumstances. First, the package limitation under visby is higher than u. Reforming the law to facilitate the use of electronic. Carriage of goods by sea act 1971 of england article 1 application of hague rules as amended. Cogsa means the carriage of goods by sea act of the united states of america approved on 16th april 1936. At the current time any known changes or effects made by subsequent legislation have been applied to the text of the legislation you are viewing by the editorial team. Ib and section 14 of uk carriage of goods by sea act cogsa 1971. Other statutory schemes harter act, hague visby and hamburg rules cogsas overarching purpose is to allocate risk of loss and create predictable liability rules on which not only carriers. Revised legislation carried on this site may not be fully up to date. List of the 17 haguecogsa defenses the voss law firm, p. Even the merchants and shippers realised the necessity of some limitation of liability beyond that given by the legal. Contents the haguevisby rules the hague rules as amended by the brussels protocol 1968 1 information on this document copy and an unof.
Extension of application of rules to carriage from ports in. English law straight bills of lading one more piece in the puzzle. The act does not use the term hague visby rules as such. The haguevisby rules the hague rules as amended by the. Even the merchants and shippers realised the necessity of some limitation of. The act applies in conjunction with the carriage of goods by sea act 1971 hereinafter cogsa 1971 under which the hague visby rules,16 as laid down in schedule 1, apply automatically to certain carriage contracts and are given the force of law. The hamburg rules are not applicable to charter parties. Secondly, the visby rules apply by force of law and often inwards and outwards. Other statutory schemes harter act, hague visby and hamburg rules cogsas overarching purpose is to allocate risk of loss and create predictable liability rules on which not only carriers but others can rely. Schedulethe hague rules as amended by the brussels. Haguevisby rules apply where shipment commenced from a port in the united kingdom, inland or internationally, as evidenced by the contract or bill of lading expressly stated that haguevisby rule applies. In these rules the following words are employed, with the mean ings set out below.
Jurisprudence on interpretation of haguevisby rules. It incorporates into english law the hague visby rules which are to be found as the schedule to the act. The haguevisby rules is a set of international rules for the international carriage of goods by. The haguevisby rules were incorporated into english law by the carriage of goods by sea act 1971. Cogsa means the carriage of goods by sea act of the united states of. Betwixt and between does the us cogsa package limitation. The popular view was that negotiable bills of lading were subject to the hague visby rules, whereas straight bills being nonnegotiable documents were not. The hague visby rules is a set of international rules for the international carriage of goods by sea. But the terms of those rules, in so far as they are contradicted by the haguevisby rules, will be ineffective if the latter rules apply by force of law. The haguevisby rules the hague rules as amended by the brussels protocol 1968 article i.
The haguevisby rules allow to the carrier to make a reasonable deviation. In uk hague visby rules are adopted in cogsa71 hague visby rules proper name hague rules as amended by brussels protocol 1968 applies to every bill of lading or document of title relating to carriage of goods between different states if. In another decision the same court considered a general paramount clause which provided that, depending upon the country of shipment, either the hague rules or the hague visby rules would apply. Rules relating to bill of lading signed at brussels on 25th august 1924. On their own terms, the hague visby rules only apply compulsorily by virtue of the carriage of goods by sea act 1971 cogsa 1971 to contracts of carriage covered by a bill of lading. Reforming the law to facilitate the use of electronic bills. Hague visby rules bill of lading social institutions. Nov 12, 2018 the united kingdom is party to the hague visby rules, which were implemented into domestic law by the carriage of goods by sea act 1971, with a number of modifications or qualifications. Is a straight bill of lading a bill of lading or similar document of title within the meaning of the hague visby rules art. The lack of a uniform international legislation on undelivered goods increases the liabilities of the carrier. United nations felt that even the hague visby rules were in favor of the ship owners. The enacting legislation for the hague visby rules is the car riage of goods by sea act cogsa1 1971. Dec 04, 2019 the haguevisby rules is a set of international rules for the international carriage of goods by sea. May 15, 2017 in our earlier article is limitation under the hague rules more generous than the haguevisby rules, the value of.
Act 1971 chapter 19 arrangement of sections section 1. The 17 haguecogsa defenses neither the carrier nor the ship shall be responsible for loss or damage arising or resulting from. The hague visby rules will compulsorily apply when the contract requires the issue of a bill of lading, even if a sea waybill is in fact issued. Liability of the sea carrier in the international carriage of. Thus i referred to so many ancient and modern english cases. Neither the carrier nor the ship shall be responsible for loss or damage arising or resulting from. Because cogsa 1924 was repealed totally by cogsa 1971, the only way that the hague rules, as opposed to the haguevisby rules, can be applied is by contractual incorporation.
Package or unit limitation under the haguevisby rules. The hague visby rules both excluded cabotage carriage, and declared that deck cargo and live animals were not to be considered as goods although the carriage of goods by sea act 1971 provided that cabotage, deck cargo and live animals are to be covered in english contracts. Mar 22, 2020 cogsa 1971 pdf carriage of goods by sea act cogsa 71 is a uk act to make the hague visby rules apply to the carriage of goods in certain circumstances. For international trade to flourish there must be an involvement in transaction of goods by sea between a buyer in one country and seller in another. In order to avoid extensive costs relating to the undelivered goods time is of essence and the carrier must act.
The bbc greenland decision 1 discusses the validity of an on deck statement on the face of a bill of lading and illustrates the effect this has on the application of the hague visby rules and a claim by cargo interests the hague visby rules the rules apply to contracts of carriage and goods as defined in article 1 of the rules as follows. But to the extent that the rotterdam rules and the hague rules cogsa share much in both concepts and rules, much of cogsa case law will be applicable in interpreting the rotterdam rules. Schedule the hague rules as amended by the brussels protocol 1968. The act applies in conjunction with the carriage of goods by sea act 1971 hereinafter cogsa 1971 under which the hague visby rules,16 as laid down in schedule 1, apply automatically to certain carriage contracts and are given the force of. If bl is issued in contracting state carriage is from a port of contracting state in every other. A basic and simplified guide of hague visby rules for. Hague visby rules are the most used rules to this date. Absolute warranty of seaworthiness not to be implied in contracts to which rules apply article 4. Understanding the carriage of goods by sea act 46 u. Absolute warranty of seaworthiness not to be implied in contracts to which rules apply. The carriage of goods by sea act cogsa is a united states statute governing the rights and responsibilities between shippers of cargo and shipowners regarding ocean shipments to and from the united states. The court concluded that forcing the shipper to investigate which set of rules, if either, had been adopted in the country of shipment and then determine how to. I compared the provisions of the haguevisby rules with the provisions of the carriage of goods by sea act.
They are a slightly updated version of the original hague rules which were if the rules apply, the entire text of rules is incorporated into the contract of carriage, and any attempt to exclude the rules is void under article iii. Undelivered goods under the law of carriage of goods by sea. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. It is essential to know about the contract that governs the carriages of goods by sea, as. The hague visby rules allow to the carrier to make a reasonable deviation. Cogsa 1971 pdf carriage of goods by sea act cogsa 71 is a uk act to make the hague visby rules apply to the carriage of goods in certain circumstances. This was the central issue in the rafaela s 1, a case in which the house of lords gave its judgment on the 16th february this year. The hague visby rules were incorporated into english law by the carriage of goods by sea act 1971. United nations convention on the carriage of goods by sea.
Throw into the mix the hamburg rules, and you have. Carriage of goods by seathe hague rules 673 owners, who were placed by the rules of common law under a burden which threatened to crush all initiative and to paralyse the industry. This was the central issue in the rafaela s 1, a case in which the house of lords gave its judgment on the 16th february this year at arbitration and in the court of appeal 2 it had been held. It was found in title 46 appendix of the united states code. Convention of 25 august 1924 for the unification of certain rules of law relating to bills of lading treaty series 1953, 109 including the provision appearing in section 1 of the accompanying protocol of signature, as that convention was amended by the protocol signed at brussels on 23 february 1968 treaty series 1979, 26 and as furthermore amended by the protocol signed. Act, neglect, or default of the master, mariner, pilot, or the servants of the carrier in the navigation or in the management of the ship. On appeal by tasman orient line cv the new zealand court of appeal reversed the decision and held that the limitation of liability under the hague rules was determined by both articles 45 and 9 and the effect of clause 6bbi was to replace the limit set out by the provisions of the rules by the. The recognised conventions are the hague rules, the hague visby rules and the hamburg rules. English law straight bills of lading one more piece i. The carriage of goods by sea act 1971 is a united kingdom act of parliament. Unification of certain rules relating bill of lading signed at brussels on 25th august 1954. The system of liability of articles iii and iv of the hague visby rules.
Steamship mutual deck cargo can liability be excluded. Legislation and principles of its interpretation will also be examined, including in particular the carriage of goods by sea act 1971 bringing into force in the uk the hague visby rules and the carriage of goods by sea act 1992. Unlike cogsa, but similar to the haguevisby rules, the rotterdam rules establish an alternative weight limitation. These rules require where the article x invokes the rules that, on demand, the carrier must provide the shipper with a bill of lading that meets the requirements of article iii. Contrary to the hague visby rules, this provision is much narrower than given by the hague visby rules. Contrary to the haguevisby rules, this provision is much narrower than given by the haguevisby rules. In the court of appeal decision in the happy ranger 1, lord justices tuckey and rix suggested that, contrary to popular wisdom, a straight bill of lading might be subject to the hague visby rules. Us cogsa united states carriage of goods by sea act. Extension of application of rules to carriage from ports in british possessions. Carriage of goods by sea act 1971 of england article 1 application of hague rules as amended article 2 contracting states etc article 3 absolute warranty of seaworthiness not to be implied in contracts to which rules apply article 4 application of act to british possessions etc. Cargo conventions comparing hague, hague visby and hamburg rules. English law deck carriage and the haguevisby rules gard. The definition of unit in the hague rules and the hague visby rules is the same and the large pieces of tuna in this case were units for the purpose of both.
This is evidenced by the fact that the carriage of goods by sea act 1971 uk does not provide for the application of uk law, given that the port of shipment is not a uk port. The majority of the court found that the hague visby rules applied by virtue of the carriage of goods by sea act 1971 in conjunction with article xa and b of the hague visby rules, but rejected an alternative argument that the wording of the clause was itself sufficient to incorporate the hague visby rules contractually for carriage from a. Hague visby rules means the hague rules as amended by the protocol signed at brussels on 23rd february 1936. Other statutory schemes harter act, hague visby and hamburg rules cogsa s overarching purpose is to allocate risk of loss and create predictable liability rules on which not only carriers. Where a non negotiable document is issued based on haguevisby rule as governing law in the receipt. In this act, the rules means the international convention for the unification of certain rule of law relating to bills of lading signed at brussels on 25th august 1924, as amended by the protocol signed at brussels on 23rd february 1968. Carriage of goods by sea act 1971 provides that the rules will have the force of law where the bill of lading concerned expressly provides that the. Jul 12, 2016 to address these weaknesses, hague rules were amended slightly and were known as hague visby rules.
Carry cargo to agreed destination without deviation. Carriage of goods by sea act 1971 chapter 19 arrangement of sections section 1. The haguevisby rules the haguevisby rules the hague rules as amended by the brussels protocol 1968 article i in these rules the following words are employed, with the meanings set out below. Straight bills of lading do the haguevisby rules apply. Sep 26, 2019 cogsa 1971 pdf carriage of goods by sea act cogsa 71 is a uk act to make the hague visby rules apply to the carriage of goods in certain circumstances. As a result of which, united nations body unctad developed hamburg rules of 1978.
822 1465 925 1035 761 663 654 916 880 1232 1518 964 157 767 711 1320 639 1038 812 1040 270 1504 405 897 1434 606 136 55 437 1458 1033 254 361